Cindy Kilkenny header image 2

Not your momma’s pot roast

January 2, 2010 at 7:51 pm --by Cindy · 5 Comments

Growing up in Oklahoma, the Sunday pot roast was a thing of legend. Fall-apart tender and heaped with mashed potatoes, green beans, and my personal favorite, dry cottage cheese, the dish still creates all kinds of warm fuzzies when served.

The problem is, I never learned how to make it.

My mother was young when she married, and she argued my poor father shouldn’t have to live through two women learning to cook, so my kitchen responsibilities were limited to eating and getting out. I don’t even remember much in the way of post-dinner dish duty.

Once on my own, my first cooking expeditions were back-of-the-box recipes. (Oh yes, I made a mean Bisquick cheeseurger pie.) Later follies included things children would eat. There was a constant battle to expand their little pallets as well as provide the required nutrients. I must have done that well, because they will all three eat almost anything these days.

The last few years have been spent exploring some classics and understanding why things turn out like they do. I still measure for baking, or like tonight when I set the water to boil for the polenta, but it’s rare that I measure at all. Instead I focus more on proportions and how flavors blend.

Tonight I made a 3-1/2 pound arm roast (thanks Ney’s!) in more of a classic boeuf bourguignon tradition. There are some steps to this one you shouldn’t short cut.

1) Dredge and brown the beef.

Many moms I knew floured their pot roast, but mine never did. While still very yummy, the gravy never thickened. You see, flouring the beef before browning means all that thickening agent is ready for the next step. (It’s much like the Asia beef using a cornstarch and soy sauce marinade from this meal.)

2) ONIONS! I used one fairly large one – still left from my farmer’s market stash of late October – but two small to medium sized onions will work as well. A carrot, finely diced, is another important ingredient for flavor and color.

3) Wine. I’ve not been one to cook with wine, but I’m learning. Tonight’s was a cup and a half or so of last night’s left over Pinot. It’s tough to duplicate the particular flavor of the gravy that’s made without this ingredient. My other secret weapon? A can of Campbell’s beef consumme. I don’t go all food snob over much, but there is absolutely no way for me to duplicate what a can of this liquid gold does for my soups and stews. Ditto a pot roast.

I didn’t exactly follow the boeuf recipe linked above. There was no bacon in my evening. (Bacon in general is a revered household food, but there was none in the fridge, and it was too blasted cold to find any.) There was no tomato paste in my sauce. (In Oklahoma, tomato and beef don’t tango much unless it’s barbecue.) Instead of a bay leaf I threw in some of my stashed rosemary. Chopped onion instead of pearl onions. No mushrooms.

Everything was done in an oval Le Creuset French oven. First the meat was browned and removed, the veges were sauteed, the meat replaced, and the liquids added. Then it went into the oven at 340 degrees for a couple of hours, and down to 300 for the last 40 minutes or so.

If you aren’t one to slow-cook beef, give this a try. It works with short ribs, stew meat, or a roast. I don’t think you’ll be disappointed.

Tonight instead of mashed or roasted potatoes, we had polenta with goat cheese. Now polenta is a fancy (Italian) way of saying cornmeal mush. Combine a ratio of 1/4 cup ground corn, white or yellow, slowly into 1 cup boiling water. Add a little butter, and if you’re feeling adventurous, a smear goat cheese or a handful of grated cheese.

It’s good.

Served under the beef with some extra carrots and a generous scoop of the pan gravy, you’re eating as well as any restaurant could provide.

The spouse joked tonight before we dug in that I should take a picture. Maybe I should have. But since I didn’t, you’ll just have to trust me and give it all a try on your own.

  • Share/Bookmark

Tags: FOOD

5 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Pat // Jan 2, 2010 at 8:50 pm

    Your spouse is right – you absolutely should include a photo! I love to *see* the result of the recipe. Maybe then you can even personalize your banner. (By the way, I do like the banner; but personalization is always nice.)

  • 2 Cindy // Jan 2, 2010 at 9:08 pm

    Karen Kingston’s Clear Your Clutter with Feng Shui. The other one you recommended is on its way from another library.

    Now that the dinner dishes are gurgling away in the dishwasher, I’m making a cup of a tea and snuggling in to read it.

  • 3 Pat // Jan 2, 2010 at 10:29 pm

    I hope you like it. The first time I read it I got so excited that I went through the house like a whirlwind! I would literally wake up early because it felt so good to clear out so many things. Every time I do a really thorough clutter clearing I am usually going through some type of personal growth and/or change myself. Anyway, I find it all pretty fascinating the way it impacts the space and the people in it. Happy reading!

  • 4 Jvee // Jan 3, 2010 at 7:23 pm

    Oh, my gosh! I just didn’t realize I failed you. You did cook a little and I can remember one night when brother ran away (hid in the van) and Daddy said “I suffered through your learning to cook – do I have to do it again?” Besides! when you were a teenager you had three (3) jobs and went to school. Couldn’t catch you long enough.
    You do very well now. The secret to pot roast is cooking it a very long time – low temp. Your grandmother was a little ahead of her time because the reason she didn’t flour it was – it added calories. Either way is fine. You thicken the gravy later.

  • 5 Cindy // Jan 3, 2010 at 9:32 pm

    He hid in the van? Oh dear. Maybe there’s a reason I don’t remember cooking at home.

Leave a Comment

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture. Click on the picture to hear an audio file of the word.
Click to hear an audio file of the anti-spam word